Not a fact anymore

The Moon’s youngest mare volcanism required a KREEP-rich mantle source enriched in heat-producing elements.

What we know now

Chang’e-5 returned lunar basalts about 2 billion years old whose chemistry points to a mantle source with little KREEP contribution. KREEP—material rich in potassium, rare-earth elements, phosphorus, and heat-producing radioactive elements—is therefore not required as the direct source of the Moon’s youngest volcanism.

Why it changed

Many young volcanic rocks occur in a KREEP-rich region of the Moon, so its extra radioactive heat seemed like a natural explanation for late volcanism. Isotope measurements of Chang’e-5 samples instead traced those basalts to a chemically depleted mantle source with little KREEP contribution.

Status
Narrowed
Category
Planetary Science
Accepted for
Not quantified
Accepted approximately
1990s–2021
Changed approximately
2021

The dark plains visible across much of the Moon are ancient lava flows. Some of these mare basalts are much younger than most lunar volcanism, raising a basic question: what kept parts of the Moon hot enough to melt so late in its history?

One leading explanation focused on KREEP. Its radioactive elements release heat as they decay, and many young mare basalts occur in the Procellarum KREEP Terrane. It was therefore reasonable to suspect that this extra heat was directly tied to their source.

Chang’e-5 made that idea testable by returning rocks from one of the Moon’s youngest volcanic regions. The basalts are about 2 billion years old, but their isotope signatures point to a chemically depleted part of the lunar mantle with little KREEP contribution.

KREEP still matters to the Moon’s thermal and chemical history. What changed was the narrower claim that a KREEP-rich mantle source was required for very late lunar volcanism. The Chang’e-5 samples show that some young lunar lava came from somewhere else, so other processes must also have helped the Moon remain volcanically active.

Evidence

Sources and what they establish

Primary research

Related entries

Or go somewhere else: